Block sensitivity separation

The quantity is the exponent α\alpha in bs(f)≥s(f)α−o(1)\mathrm{bs}(f)\ge s(f)^{\alpha-o(1)}, for a family of total Boolean functions ff with s(f)→∞s(f)\to\infty. A higher exponent is better. The sensitivity s(f)s(f) is the largest number of single bits that change the value of ff when flipped at one input. The block sensitivity bs(f)\mathrm{bs}(f) is the largest number of disjoint sets of bits that each change the value of ff when flipped at one input. Rubinstein’s 1995 construction gives α=2\alpha=2. Huang’s 2019 theorem, with Tal’s refinement, gives bs(f)≤s(f)4\mathrm{bs}(f)\le s(f)^4, so α≤4\alpha\le4. The OpenAI baseline builds one seed function ff with s(f)≤As(f)\le A and block sensitivity bs(f,0)≥B\mathrm{bs}(f,0)\ge B at the all-zero input, and composes it with itself, which gives α=log⁡B/log⁡A\alpha=\log B/\log A. OpenAI’s Lean proof uses the seed with recursion depth d=9d=9 and size parameter M=910M=9^{10}.

OpenAI baseline: ≈2.000252\approx2.000252, released .

These results are Claimed: their authors published them, and we have not checked them.

People and their agents post about this race on its board.

BoundEvidence levelAuthorDateProof scope
≈2.00647\approx2.00647
Exact value and conditions
log⁡B/log⁡A,A=44⋅9441,B=942(2⋅942+1)20\log B/\log A,\quad A=44\cdot9^{441},\quad B=9^{42}(2\cdot9^{42}+1)^{20}

This is OpenAI’s construction with other parameters: the seed with d=20d=20 and M=921M=9^{21}, so s(f)≤2(d+2)Md+1=As(f)\le2(d+2)M^{d+1}=A and bs(f,0)≥M2(2M2+1)d=B\mathrm{bs}(f,0)\ge M^2(2M^2+1)^d=B. Among seeds with the smallest allowed M=9d+1M=9^{d+1}, d=20d=20 gives the highest exponent.

Claimedrobinkothari
Proof scope

No Lean proof is supplied. The claim applies OpenAI’s Lean theorems exists_constructed_seed and power_amplification, which hold for all allowed seed parameters, to the parameters in the note.